TheCoolist is a mood board for your headspace.

    Arnold Schwarzenegger, 79: the ‘light and heavy’ rule he follows to stay strong as he ages
  1. TheCoolist
  2. Sports

Arnold Schwarzenegger, 79: the ‘light and heavy’ rule he follows to stay strong as he ages

You do everything right. Three times a week, you pick up the same pair of light dumbbells, do your sets of 10 and leave the heavier ones on the rack, because that feels safe. And yet, year after year, carrying groceries up the stairs or getting out of a low chair takes a little more effort than it used to.

This is not your fault, and light weights are not the problem. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who turned 79 this year, has been making that point in his Arnold’s Pump Club newsletter. As the newsletter puts it, “Whether you go heavy or light, the key is pushing intensity near the point of failure.” The catch is what happens when light is the only thing you ever lift.

Why light weights alone can leave strength on the table

Arnold Schwarzenegger, 79: the ‘light and heavy’ rule he follows to stay strong as he ages
Arnold Schwarzenegger, 79: the ‘light and heavy’ rule he follows to stay strong as he ages © serts

Your muscles are built from different kinds of fibers. Slow-twitch fibers handle endurance. Fast-twitch fibers produce power and speed, the kind you use to catch yourself on a stair or stand up quickly. And they don’t age the same way. A 2019 review in the journal Bone notes that fast fibers undergo a more profound age-related atrophy than slow ones.

In a Nov. 10 issue of his newsletter, Schwarzenegger explained why that matters. Your body recruits slow-twitch fibers first and brings in fast-twitch fibers as the effort climbs. A light set taken close to failure eventually reaches them, but heavy sets get there sooner. Since fast-twitch fibers tend to shrink first as we get older, he wrote, lifting only light may leave them underused. His rule: everyone should lift heavier weight, relative to their own strength, at least once or twice a week.

His note lines up with a new analysis by Dorian Varovic, Stian Larsen and Jozo Grgic, published in Frontiers in Physiology in October. The researchers pooled studies in which people had thigh-muscle biopsies before and after an average of about 10 weeks of heavy or light training, and found a possible pattern by fiber type across loads.

How to mix light and heavy

You don’t need to train like a bodybuilder. Here is how to apply the rule:

  • Keep light days. For most sessions, pick a weight you can control with good form and take each set until the last reps feel truly hard.
  • Add one or two heavy sets a week. Choose one key move, such as a squat to a chair, a leg press or a row, and use a weight you can only lift for a handful of good reps.
  • Make “heavy” personal. It means heavy for you, relative to your own strength, not the weight on the next bench.
  • Build up slowly. Increase the weight in small steps over several weeks rather than jumping straight to your limit.
  • Plan B if heavy hurts. His newsletter notes you can build muscle either by lifting more weight or by using a lighter weight for more reps. If a heavier load bothers your joints, go lighter and push closer to failure.

Strength is only one part of aging well. Staying active also shows up among the happiest people after 60, along with friendships and curiosity.

What the science can’t say yet

The fiber-type findings are early. The authors of the new analysis describe their estimates as exploratory and hypothesis-generating, and note that only a small number of studies were included. At very light loads, around 20 to 30% of a person’s maximum, the differences they modeled were not statistically certain.

Heavy lifting also isn’t for everyone on day one. If you are new to strength training, or you have a heart condition, osteoporosis, a joint replacement or ongoing pain, talk to your doctor or a physical therapist before adding heavier sets, and ask a qualified trainer to check your form. Stop any exercise that causes sharp pain.

Keep your light days, add one heavy set a week and let effort, not the number on the dumbbell, do the work. That’s the trick.