Investment gurus say that it pays to hold on to an asset that has a history of wins since a performer will always lay a golden egg. And the best mens peacoats are a great investment when it comes to winter outerwear.
This jacket is a classic rich lode of style and utility, warm and endlessly versatile. Its neat, easy to style tapered silhouette has graced the shoulders of many a star, including Daniel Craig’s Bond, Robert Redford, and James Dean.
Few clothing items are as deserving of the honors of the term ‘classic’ as the officer’s peacoat. It was so perfect on inception that its winning design has been consistent since it was first worn in the 1800s. It has weathered the damp and cold mists of the docks and decks and made it through several wars.
The reefer jacket is now a casual winter style that everyone turns to when the mercury dips. You will find it all over the city streets, its silhouette drawing envious glances by the gallons. You can choose to buy a peacoat as per a budget or its authenticity to the original design.
Labels and designers have tweaked the jacket’s design and fabric to produce fall season budget items that look good but may not outlast a few winters. That designer full length navy pea coat’s price tag may feel slightly over the odds but its accuracy, feel, comfort, practicality, durability, and style are worth every penny.
Best Men’s Peacoat to Wear
Looking to find your perfect officer’s jacket? Below are some of the best there are in the market. Let’s dive right in and help you choose your weather-resistant wardrobe staple for autumn, fall, winter, and early spring.
The Brits may not have created the original peacoat (we have the Dutch pijjekker to thank for that), they certainly incorporated it into their glorious navy. Thankfully, you no longer have to be a petty officer braving the rough winter seas to don this piece of history–Percival has seen to that.
Hailing from East London, Percival has a penchant for experimentation. However, in the case of their peacoat, they have elected to remain faithful to the original silhouette, giving it just a nip here and a tuck there to make it a touch more sleek and modern. The jump from double to single breast is the most evident of these updates.
In every other way, though, this could easily see duty on the high seas alongside the original article. A Percival men’s peacoat is sturdy as a rule, featuring a substantive blend of wool for warmth and polyester for durability. It’ll hold its structure against the elements, while layering with dignity over the rest of your outfit without bulk or loss of mobility.
We also like that Percival keeps things affordable–but not cheap. No corners have been cut to bring you a spiritually faithful update of a UK classic.
A Day’s March isn’t content to beat the fashion industry’s drum of fast, disposable fashion that trashes the planet. Instead, they make durable wardrobe pieces designed to last as long as possible. Applying this ethos to their heavy-duty Devonport peacoat, they have made BIFL quality available to all–without the bespoke price tag.
This handsome men’s double-breasted peacoat features a beefy 820gr wool blend that won’t stretch or deform even after years of daily use. It comes thoughtfully constructed from their Portuguese production facility, where employees are paid a living wage and work with dignity.
Moreover, A Day’s March participates in an aggressive carbon offsetting project to ensure they’re doing their part. Though they themselves admit this is only a stopgap on the way to more meaningful sustainability from the ground up–a goal they’ve built their entire brand identity around.
The Devonport peacoat fits true to size, and true to form as a dead ringer for the original US Navy peacoat.
Wool blends are fine, but for some there is not substitute for the full monty. Wax London‘s Condo Coat features a gorgeous black Melton wool, which will bring many to the table on its merits alone.
Indeed, this robust twill weave is ideally suited to life as a peacoat; it is unyieldingly strong and durable. And being such a dense package, it does a wonderful job of keeping moisture and wind out, and body warmth in. Fraying and pilling aren’t really an issue with Melton wool. It’ll continue to look and feel its best for years without requiring you to baby it.
But, for all its indestructibility, this Wax London long mens peacoat is surprisingly genteel. It offers a flattering fit that doesn’t overdo the slimming modernizations, instead leaning into the traditional spirit of this rugged garment. The Condo Coat looks and feels just like the heirloom piece it is, and we’re willing to bet you’ll find a reason to wear it all the time.
The brutal Spartans wore their deep crimson chitons for their practicality and the fact that they would disguise bloody gashes in battle. The naval peacoat like the chiton is a practical item, just like many martial menswear staples. Their form always follows function.
Buck Mason’s Melton Admiral double breasted peacoat design stays extremely close to the reefer jacket of the post World War II era. The war era peacoats had a minimum of eight visible buttons. Post-war, the number of buttons fell to six visible ones to allow for a larger lapel.
The peacoat has distinctive functional features such as slash pockets, wool fabric, and a tall collar. The deep indigo color, for instance, was supposed to resist salty seawater and the sun’s effects on the coat. It could also veil much grime. Wool is not only naturally flame resistant, but stays warm should it become wet.
Pop the peacoat’s collar and you have broad lapels shielding your neck from the worst of chilly winds. Shimmy up a ship’s rigging and your peacoat will protect your skin against chaffing. The double button rows allow the rope to slide up, snag-free.
This Buck Mason officer’s coat has original naval specifications Melton wool poly blend, a 35oz weighty fabric. Like the original WWII era design, it has corduroy lined hand warming pockets. Its lining is not nylon, but smooth and soft to touch brushed Japanese satin.
Its buttons are authentic anchor peacoat type and it has a button throatlatch. The Buck Mason Melton Admiral coat is a stylish medium price range jacket, trying not to be anything other than a practical, full range of motion peacoat.
The history buff looking for a retro look will flip over at the authentic features of the Buzz Rickson US Navy 1910 model jacket.
Naval peacoats from the World War 1 era were longer than the current reiteration of the reefer jacket. They had 10 or more buttons adorned with the military anchor insignia with 13 stars around it. They also had flapped hand warmer pockets at the waist, a feature that you will not find in the newer peacoat styles.
The Buzz Rickson US Navy 1910 peacoat is made in Japan, so you can expect sartorial military precision. This coat like the Schott NYC is 36 oz Melton wool but its pockets are corduroy lined, not nylon. A premium product, it has black urea buttons, organic, and highly resistant to heat treatment. They are a perfect imitation of the classic horn buttons.
This 1910 design’s collar is large and has a throatlatch. So if you are looking for the old quality that knowledgeable folk rave about, get this top of the range stuff.
Buzz Rickson uses vintage looms to create this bygone treasure’s fabric. They then sew the coat on old-school Union Special machines, giving the final product a genuine peacoat look. No knapping of pills into ugly little balls or a poly-wool flimsy fabric feel.
This peacoat will outlive all your winters. Some websites claim the Buzz Rickson navy coat is actually of Kelsey wool construction, a heavier staple of old navy peacoats. Kelsey ages beautifully, but you can only find it in the rare vintage item.
The Buzz Rickson jacket is so authentic that it stars in the North Atlantic warfare movie starring Tom Hanks, “Grey Hound”. The prolific actor wears this officer’s coat, but with the gilt buttons, that befits the officer rank.
It has become much harder to get a hold of a genuine US Navy issue peacoat. The army has changed the sailor’s outerwear, favoring a black synthetic parka over the traditional wool jacket.
The peacoat is now an optional piece that the sailors can purchase at their own cost. In doing so, the East Coast production of peacoats could drop from 60,000 a year to lows of less than 5000. If you are looking for this iconic midnight blue look, you need either to purchase vintage or scour online vendors and consignment stores for old stock.
Alternatively, you can go for a Schott NYC Melton wool double-breasted number, which is as close to the US Navy ideal as you can get. Like its military crony, the Schott NYC coat is a 32 oz Melton wool product complete with a quilted lining.
Melton wool is one of the best peacoats for men and one of the most robust clothing materials because of its dense, thick weave that will keep you warm in the most brutal weather. Melton wool is a twill form of weave that has a fuzzy feel and is rigid and thick. It has a minimal fray, perfect at water wicking, and is almost weatherproof.
The Schott NYC peacoat is original US Navy 1050 grams or 34 oz. heavily fulled wool, beefy, and significantly warm. It is as good as heavyweight vintage as you can get out there. This reefer jacket has other classic features such as eight naval fouled anchor buttons and a vented back. You can get it in black, dark oxford, oxford grey, navy, and new navy color variants.
The crew at J.Crew has held on to the peacoat’s 30s design. Their take on the classic naval coat is an effortless straight cut coat that will last you a long time. The J.Crew Dock coat is of a wool and polyamide blend.
It has PrimaLoft insulation, a design of the US army that gives sublime levels of warmth even when wet. PrimaLoft is lightweight and will resist moisture better than the ordinary down-filled coat. Should you be looking for a mens black peacoat with a little bit more length, this is the coat for you. It will hit your mid-thigh level, and its slim fit will flatter most silhouettes.
This dark coat has slim sleeves, a convertible collar, and a row of four buttons down its right front. It features a collar button design for inclement weather. Wear it sparingly or layer it up, this jacket will still look amazing. You can dress it up since it will cover the length of the ordinary suit, or simply wear it alongside your track pants or jeans.
This double-breasted Asian brand jacket might intimidate some buyers, but it is a solid buy. The Chouyatou coat has a turndown lapel collar complete with three-button sleeves. It is a bargain product that you can hand wash at home.
It has wool, polyester, and viscose blend, with the wool making up 30% of its fabric, a factor that significantly contributes to its low price range. The inner lining is polyester. This military man’s coat has few inner pockets and external side slant pockets that will keep your hands warm.
It comes in grey or solid black hues, meaning that you can slip into it for your formal or casual wear engagements.
This jacket is a 35% wool item. It has 65% rayon and its lining is pure nylon. Like the Chouyatou coat, the Tam Ware coat is also a budget item that may not be perfect for the coldest of winters. That said, this peacoat has one of the best fits you can find and it won’t be bulky.
Its shoulders make a perfect fit, and so is its torso width and length. It has five coat sizes, and boldly strays away from the traditional navy legacy to an attractive shade of charcoal and black. You can wear it with just about any color of clothing and turn all the heads in the room.
This steal of a reefer jacket is double-breasted and you can wear it in two different styles. First, button it up on the coldest of days, and keep your neck area all warm and cozy. Second, you can show off its slick collar and keep the wind off your neck. The only challenge that the Tam Ware buyers seem to have with this peacoat is the quality of the button craftsmanship.
This peacoat is a 70% wool and polyester blend product, and such a good deal for its price range. It is excellently priced for a high wool content item. It has a classic double-breasted design with single-button cuffs. Its buyers love that it has multiple size options for the perfect fit, no wonder it fits as one of the best peacoats for men.
One rule of thumb you should observe when ordering your stylish coat is its fit. The best peacoats naturally taper at the waist then flare slightly at the hips to allow effortless movement. This peacoat’s close fit should make you warm and flatter your shape. It should ooze style whether you are out at sea or work.
The BGSD men’s classic officer’s coat will give you a touch of tradition, a hint of the urbane, and a full measure of boldness. And when you finally purchase one, remember it has a large fit, so you might need to order a size down.
There are stylish peacoats out there with a budget tag. Most casual observers will barely tell the difference between a bargain reefer jacket and a designer piece. These snazzy coats have a gorgeous style, which rarely betrays a good deal item. The major difference between an affordable peacoat and a jacket that costs at least five times as much is their durability.
Pricey coats from brands such as Buck Mason, Buzz Rickson, or the Brooks Brothers can last for decades with good care. The Nautica Men’s peacoat is an affordable wool and poly blend number in a double-breasted design. It might not be pure wool, but it is of high quality.
You can hardly tell the difference between a Nautica peacoat and other high street brands. For this reason, it is one of the most popular peacoats on Amazon. This coat has a sharp lapel collar and multiple pockets for storage. Its six buttons might disappoint the keen peacoat fan because they are not top brass at all. The original pea coat had eight to ten naval anchor fastenings. Brands substitute the metallic fastenings with horn or plastic.
This coat’s buttons are your run off the mill dark grey, large overcoat buttons that will not impress. Should you prefer a more naval style type of fastening, order some peacoat large buttons for alterations on delivery.
That said, the Nautica coat’s clean-cut and the stitching will elevate your wardrobe. It is perfect for layering and will go along well with your merino wool sweater. Alternatively, button it up over a turtleneck. One complaint that most users have is that it has larger than usual fitting, forcing many buyers to send it back for a more fitting size.
QUICK BUYING GUIDE – Men’s Pea Coats
The peacoat is versatile, classy, timeless, and keeps you warm and looking good. So how do you pick the right peacoat for you? Let’s look at some of the top considerations for the discerning buyer.
Traditionally, peacoats were made out of 100% wool. The thick wool fabric is ideal for resisting color fading and is durable in salt and water. Wool is a natural flame retardant and weather resistant.
While a 100% wool peacoat may be expensive for most people, you can find comparable quality in one blended with about 20% synthetic fiber. Fibers like polyester and nylon may actually increase the coat’s strength, warmth, and durability.
If you can afford 100% wool, go for wool types like Melton wool. It’s dense and warm, yet provides a smooth touch to the skin.
Find a peacoat with an internal lining that keeps you feeling warm and snug. A good lining will feel smooth next to your skin. Avoid linings made out of materials that may cause itching or scratching.
You can wear your peacoat with a sweater, shirt, hoodie, or turtleneck. The styling, pairing, and layering possibilities are endless.
However, in most cases, the peacoat doesn’t look good if layered with a blazer or suit. It’s a tighter fit than an overcoat so it would be impractical to layer a peacoat over dressy clothes.
Related Reading: 24 Ways to Wear a Suit Better
Fitting a Men’ Peacoat
Start with how the shoulder fits. If the shoulder seams don’t fall right where your shoulder ends and your biceps begin. If the seam is higher than your shoulder, the peacoat is too small. If the seam is lower than your shoulder joint, the peacoat is too big.
Around the torso, you likely want a snug fit but not too tight. You don’t want to squeeze your chest or belly. When fitting a new peacoat, move your arms around and check whether you can move your arms freely without finding it difficult to breathe. If the seams feel like they might burst, then the peacoat is probably too small. If you can move freely without feeling like the coat is hanging on you, then that coat fits pretty well.
When it comes to the length, your peacoat should be shorter than your typical overcoat. When fitting the peacoat, drop your arms free and ball your hands in a fist. For men, the bottom hem of your peacoat should be around the same height as your knuckles. For women, the hem can be a few inches higher.
When layering, your outermost layer should be the longest. Ensure that the peacoat’s sleeves cover at least up to your wrist even when you’re wearing other heavy garments inside the coat. While with a suit you can show your shirt cuffs, with a peacoat, show no cuffs. At the same time, you don’t want your peacoat to be too long so that it appears to be swallowing your hand.
See Also: How to Wear Cuffed Pants
Peacoats protect you from cold and rain. Since they are nautical coats, peacoats are meant to protect your torso, neck, and face from the spray of ocean water. So when you’re fitting your coat, make sure the collar lapel lies flat against your chest. If the lapel bulges out, then your chest will be exposed to wind and water sprays.
Mens Peacoat Reviews: Conclusion
At this point, we’ve covered everything you need to know about selecting a mens wool pea coat. No matter your style or budget, you can rest easy knowing you’ve made a solid investment in your wardrobe and personal style. Our list contains everything from wool blends to top-shelf Melton; mass manufacturers to boutique, sustainable brands. If you’re still not sure, give our handy buyer’s guide another read to give you some context for your purchase.
What is your favorite mens peacoat brand? Do you have any styling tips to help your fellow man wear it better? Leave us a comment below!